Baluch Resistance: between Scylla of violence and Charybdis of failure

0
617

Context

This is a political war and it calls for discrimination in killing.” (John Paul Vann, U.S. adviser in Vietnam)

The recent killing of Prof.Nazima Talib in Quetta, Baluchistan, has once again called into question the logic of indiscriminate violence against the non-combatant, non-Baluch settlers in the province.

It has turned the focus of attention not only to the Baluch guerrilla fighters but has simultaneously put those, who support a non-violent Baluch struggle, on the spot.

Writing about the potential US policy towards the Baluchistan, Selig S. Harrison noted in his 1981 book In Afghanistan’s Shadow that, “with respect to the Baluch issue, the American goal should be to forestall the necessity for a choice between the Scylla of supporting repressive counterinsurgency programs and the Charybdis of supporting Baluch independence.”

Indeed both the friends and foes of the Baluch have had to follow this impossible to negotiate path. The state players like the USA, former Soviet Union and India have erred – by design or default- in favor of the Pakistani state, while treading this regional policy tightrope.

For the individual and politically or apolitically organized supporters, sympathizers and fellow travelers of the Baluch struggle, it has been a rather straightforward matter where they have consistently condemned the repressive tactics of the Pakistani state machinery while openly endorsing the Baluch cause.

Be it the 1971 joining with the Parari fighters, in Marri hills, of the “London Group” boys or lending open – albeit tepid – political support from Wali Khan to Asif Zardari, the Baluch struggle has had almost unanimous backing from the leftist and center-left circles of Pakistan.

Context This is a political war and it calls for discrimination in killing.” (John Paul Vann, U.S. adviser in Vietnam) The recent killing of Prof.Nazima Talib in Quetta, Baluchistan, has once again called into question the logic of indiscriminate violence against the non-combatant, non-Baluch settlers in the province. It has turned the focus of attention not only to the Baluch…

This article is in the PoliTact Archive.
Archived articles are included in the Premium and Enterprise packages.
or

Upgrade to Premium or Enterprise

Pick any plan — full access starts immediately.